Protein disulfide isomerase (PDI), the chief endoplasmic reticulum (ER) resident oxidoreductase chaperone, is known to catalyze the maturation of disulfide bond-containing proteins primarily through oxidation and isomerization functions. The rate-determining step in the oxidative regeneration path of disulfide bond-containing proteins generally couples chemical thiol-disulfide-exchange reactions to a physical conformational folding reaction. We have determined the impact of PDI and its subdomains on the rate-determining step in ribonuclease A folding and on the physical structure-forming step of select ER-processed proteins including RNase A. This was facilitated through application of a novel chemical tool to exclusively populate native disulfide-containing intermediates in unstructured forms. The described biochemical inroad permits a deconvoluted study of the physical half-process in the rate-determining step from its chemical counterpart. Analysis of folding kinetics of RNase A and other proteins reveals that the highly evolved oxidoreductase activity of PDI masks its chaperone-like activity, impedes conformational folding of ER-processed proteins, and limits its potential to accelerate the rate-determining step in oxidative regeneration. Implications of the heretofore unknown and anomalous self-limiting behavior of PDI are discussed in the context of oxidative maturation and misfolding in vivo.